POLL: Should $1 Bills be Replaced with Coin?
Can we learn to love the $1 coin, if it will save billions?
Americans have resisted the dollar coin. We like our small denominations in paper.
For savings like that, can we learn to carry them?
On the pro-side of the change, the coin has a longer shelf life. Coins can last decades, where the paper bills typically have to be retired after four or five years, according to a report in the Boston Globe.
On the negative side, the paper bill would have to be completely eliminated for the savings to accrue. And it would take several years and up-front expenses to produce the coin.
Advocates point to the recent experience in Canada, where the $1 coin has proven a huge hit. And now a $2 coin has been introduced.
Should the U.S. drop the dollar bills and make the switch? Tell us what you think by voting in the poll.
arnold
7:42 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
We already have a $1 coin and it isn't very popular, too heavy. And the Susan B. Anthony didn't work too well either. To really save some money start with the bloated salary and perks of our elected officials, travel expenses, foreign travel etc. - and they can start at the top with the upcoming $4 million Hawaii vacation.
Nancy Carens
7:48 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
It'll save us 4.4 billion over the next 30 years. That'll keep us from going over the fiscal cliff.
Personally, I like paper. It's less bulky.
Mark Cain
8:25 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Yes, we should put Obama's face on it along with his face on the food stamp program.
Joescarp
8:40 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
A great idea...other than the fact that no one will use it. Idiots!!!
Rhaegar Targaryen
9:37 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
You'd have to use it eventually if they were phasing out the paper dollar.
Milford Senior Man
9:05 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
I think we should switch to a dollar coin. Lets face it, a dollar is not worth much at all any more. The older dollar coins were a flop because the paper dollar is still around. If the paper dollar is gone, then watch how quickly the dollar coin becomes popular. Coins last much longer, saving us a lot of money.
Rajiv Agarwal
9:37 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
We already have a coin. If we want to help save money, we should start to use what is available.
David Pacheco
10:04 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Canada has had $1 coins called loonies (because of the loon on the reverse) and have $2 coins called twonies. It took awhile to get use to but is working well there. I haven't heard any Canadians wanting paper $1 & $2 bills when I visited friends up there
David Nolta
10:14 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Yes to the coins! If, as we are told, they will save us money in the long run (a concept that seems so foreign to some people), what's the problem? As to their being heavy-- Americans could use the exercise. A little metal in the pocket has been a noble aspiration and a universal source of self-esteem since ancient times.
Larry Stone
10:30 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Let's save money in other areas...bring the cost of oil/energy down. Build the pipeline from Canada, frack some more, drill some more, coal gasification.....Dollar coins never were popular. let's not foist it on us! I like paper collars. Let Europe have the dollar/euro coins.
Andy Koenigsberg
9:42 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
Just so you know, the price of oil is set on the global commodities market so regardless of whether we are energy independent, it won't affect the price of oil. Ask anyone in Canada which is energy independent. They pay the same price for gasoline we do. We will also be energy independent ourselves in about a decade, thanks to fracking, so we don't need to buy oil from Canada and ship it down to us through the Keystone pipeline.
Rob Fossey
10:37 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
This is what I call a layup.
1) Most people will still predominantly carry the twenty dollar bill
2) Eliminate the penny
3) Reduce the size/weight and thus cost of the nickel while we are at it
We need to start ACTING on things and moving towards fiscal responsibility. This should be covered by common sense, which we seem to have so little of nowadays.
Joe Kane
10:41 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Currency should be exchanged electronically wherever possible. Reduce the amount of both paper money and coins over the next 30 years by taking it out of circulation and not making any more new bills or coins. It can still be valid, but debit cards with security passwords are the way to go.
JB
11:10 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Coins at least have some value in the metals to produce the coin. Who knows what the paper and electronic currency is backed up by these days.
Andy Koenigsberg
9:43 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
A penny costs far more to produce than it is worth. One of the great reasons to get rid of it.
Dan Breyfogle
11:12 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Perhaps we should ask retailers what they would prefer....to run a more efficient till. It seems to me, moving pennies around no longer makes sense (5 seconds of work at minimum wage). I personally will accept change (get it?) that increases the efficiency of commerce. Credit and debit cards may be nice, but the retailer gets dinged for transactions.
AG
11:33 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
We cant even get over the negotiation of the fiscal cliff let alone to attempt to convert dollars of paper to coins. if the democrats want them them the republicans will not. The coins may be useful for our bankrupt selectman.
Jeremy Bleecher
11:42 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Yes, as long as it is a different color. Europe (1 Euro) and the UK (1 pound) use coins worth more than the dollar. A 2012 dollar is the equivalent of 1 1970's quarter anyway. Let;s get rid of the one cent coin. That would save even more.
Neil Licht
11:56 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012
My pants pockets are not really designed to be bloated with lots of weighty coins. try putting coin change from a $10 bill of which you spend $9 back into your pocket. Nine space taking weighty and pocket tearing coins.
What will industry's cost to change all the automated machines that take paper money be?
There are enough other bloated "support"costs in every level of government that, if removed, could deliver a payback far greater than the so called savings associated with inconviencing all of us. How come that approach seems never to gain momentum. Hum...
Joescarp
1:01 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Hey. If it works for the one dollar coin, why not a two dollar coin and a ten dollar coin and a 20 dollar coin, etc.? Think of all the money we'll save! Not to mention all the jingling...which is especially welcome at Christmas (or can I use that word anymore?).
Papabarn
1:29 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Just make sure the dollar coin FEELS different from a quarter. When I go to Canada, I can tell by feel which coin is a dollar (loonie) which is a two dollar (twonie) coin and which is a quarter with no problem. It's really not rocket science and I fail to understand why the States has such a problem with it. Done right it works just fine. Canada dumped it's paper dollar in 1987 and the changeover doesn't seem to have destroyed many pockets since then. Just in case anyone is wondering (and to head off the "their dollar ain't worth" argument), today: 1.00 CAD =1.00659 USD [source: http://www.xe.com/ucc/convert/?Amount=1&From=CAD&To=USD ].
Kira Gagarin
1:43 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Works great in Europe with 1 and 2 Euro coins. I liked everything about it including emptying out my change jar and getting like 80$, wahooo. Living in Spain I often asked why we still use paper dollar bills. Hope this happens soon.
Gerald C W Heng Sr.
6:34 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
The Savings on Coinage is long overdue,in the UK many years ago they phased out the Shillings for Pence because of inflation the Pounds and Pence are better measure of economic value, no currency in Pence as paper. Uncle Sam has a Budget Cliff Hanger problem, anything that saves money for the Treasury should be a God Send ! The Phantom of the GOP Opera Grover Norquist on the No Tax Hike Scenario is a Killer of the American National Pax Americana of the recent Presidential Election ! Gerald Heng Sr.Metrowest Boston,MA.
Walter White
7:53 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Dollar coins will save money...only to have the govement spend it on something else. Will I see the savings in one of the 50 types of taxes I pay? I doubt it.
David Nolta
9:45 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
We all pay taxes. And we all benefit from them. I hope with Sam that we all share the benefits.
Ray Fellows
10:10 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
Save money for what? We dont have a money problem, we bring in almost 6 trillion a year. We have a SPENDING problem. I for one am sick of paying ever increasing taxes only to see my money spent to enrich others. I want to see an accounting for EVERY dollar we spend. If nonprofits are required to have complete transparency, so should the government.
Any time you spend the public's money, you should be able to justify EVERY penny you spend of OUR tax dollars. We make that happen, we will be back on the road to PERMANENT financial recovery!
Papabarn
10:55 pm on Saturday, December 1, 2012
"I want to see an accounting for EVERY dollar we spend. If nonprofits are required to have complete transparency, so should the government.
Any time you spend the public's money, you should be able to justify EVERY penny you spend of OUR tax dollars. ".
Ah, Ray, The DOD, NSA, CIA and some agencies that "don't exist" would NEVER allow for that to happen. IMHO, I think even an honest accounting by DOD would uncover billions [yup, I said "billions"] in waste, abuse and fraud, truly dwarfing what is allocated to and spent on "entitlements" and non-corporate "welfare". Apologies for drifting off-topic here.
Barb Nahoumi
10:01 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
One two letter word------NO.
Ed Bertorelli
10:08 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
Hasn't worked in the past and does anyone thing the Federal Government can successfully market this ?? their other semi-public venture the Post Office is almost kaput....you would need to eliminate the penny and develop a coin that doesn't feel like a quarter to allow room in the change drawers of registers- bring on the two dollar bill that New England phenom.
SalemCat
10:48 am on Sunday, December 2, 2012
The Dollar Coins are TOO BIG, and do not reflect the actual value of a Dollar these days.
The NEW Dollar Coin should be the size of a Penny, or even smaller.
Alison
2:21 pm on Sunday, December 2, 2012
Yes and no. If we eleminate the dollar bill then we would save trees but adding another coin would be confusing. Also it would make wallets much more bulky and harder to find dollars. Also think about the cash registers they have specific spots for dollar BILLS all cash registers would have to be remade.
Alison
2:21 pm on Sunday, December 2, 2012
also it would be to easy to lose and mix up
Greg Schuler
7:47 am on Monday, December 3, 2012
After living in Australia for a few years, I've always felt they had a much better currency. The bills are made of an untearable plastic no thicker than our paper bills. Each denomination is a slightly different size which is a huge benefit for visually impaired people. They also had one and two dollar coins which were not really that heavy. Perhaps the smartest thing they did was get rid of their penny! We should have done that years ago. Sometimes change is good! (pun intended)